Stop Posting Crap! Why Your Social Media Isn’t Getting Leads | Ep. 313 w/ Jen McKee
Episode 313 · 56 min · March 12, 2026

Stop Posting Crap! Why Your Social Media Isn’t Getting Leads | Ep. 313 w/ Jen McKee

Jen McKee of Keyheart Marketing explains why cookie-cutter graphics fail and how home service contractors can use authentic video to build leads over time.

About this episode

Jen McKee, founder of Keyheart Marketing, joined the podcast to discuss what actually works in social media for home service contractors. The core argument is straightforward: generic graphics and stock photos get ignored, while authentic video content that shows who you are and what you do every day builds the visibility that eventually converts to leads. Organic social media works like a snowball, producing little at first but compounding over time for contractors who stay consistent for two or more years.

Keyheart uses a three-part content framework where roughly half of all posts are designed purely to show up in the feed and earn engagement. The other portions cover educational content and sales-oriented posts. On paid social, Facebook ads can generate real lead volume, but only when the creative is strong, the offer is clear (tune-up specials were cited as a consistently high-ROI option), and the internal team is set up to respond quickly and book the leads that come in. A client paying his team per booked lead was cited as an example of a 40 to 60 percent booking rate, compared to much lower rates at companies with passive follow-up habits.

For contractors who have no social presence at all, the simplest starting point is documenting daily work on a personal or business Facebook page. Sharing a photo or short video of whatever is happening on the job that day, without heavy editing or overthinking, is enough to begin building an audience. Keyheart partners with local videographers to run a full content shoot in the first 30 days, then builds out organic posting on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube before layering in paid awareness and lead generation campaigns.

On the question of AI, the conversation noted that current AI tools can assist with editing and caption writing but cannot replace authentic human content. The two content styles that perform best right now are completely unedited, raw footage or a highly polished ongoing series. Anything in between tends to underperform. Both hosts agreed that authenticity will continue to win as audiences grow fatigued by AI-generated content.

Key takeaways

  • Start by posting a photo or short video of whatever you are doing that day on your personal or business Facebook page, without editing or overthinking it.
  • Aim for roughly 50 percent of your social content to be designed for engagement and feed visibility, not just promotion.
  • Before running Facebook ads, make sure your team has a fast, dedicated follow-up process in place because social leads require more active conversion than search leads.
  • Tune-up offers consistently produce a strong return on Facebook ads across markets and seasons because the goal is getting into the home, not closing on the first call.
  • Organic social builds slowly, so commit to consistency for at least two to three years before judging whether it is working.
  • Content featuring your actual employees and job sites attracts job applicants as well as customers, making social media a recruiting tool as well as a marketing one.