Yelp Responds To Contractors’ Biggest Complaints | Part 1
Episode 328 · 41 min · June 30, 2026

Yelp Responds To Contractors’ Biggest Complaints | Part 1

Yelp's COO sits down with two hundred-million-dollar contractors to address the review complaints that home service businesses ask about most.

Guests Jed Nachman Chris Bache

Watch this episode

About this episode

Yelp COO Jed and Hatch CEO Chris Bake joined the Home Services VIP podcast to address contractor frustrations with the platform, particularly around how reviews are filtered and displayed. Two co-hosts, both owners of hundred-million-dollar HVAC and plumbing operations, brought direct complaints from a contractor poll where more than 80 percent of submitted questions focused on the review process.

Jed explained that Yelp uses hundreds of signals to determine whether a review is recommended or not, with a stated goal of surfacing trustworthy, high-quality content rather than maximizing volume. He noted that 70 percent of Yelp reviews are three stars or above and pointed to an FTC study showing Yelp has a wider review distribution than competing platforms. He also acknowledged that review scores on Yelp tend to run lower than on Google or other directories, and that the platform intentionally does not reward businesses for soliciting reviews from customers.

The conversation also touched on the Hatch acquisition. Yelp purchased the AI-focused software company for roughly 270 million dollars after an existing partnership showed the two products complemented each other, particularly around lead management and automated follow-up. Hatch added 65 employees in the 30 days following the acquisition as Yelp looks to expand its capabilities in that area.

Jed acknowledged that Yelp needs to do a better job educating service professionals on how to use the platform effectively beyond just collecting reviews, including claiming and optimizing their pages, responding to reviews, and using available free and paid tools. This episode is part one of two, with the second part covering lead transparency, geographic performance, and what top-performing contractors do differently on the platform.

Key takeaways

  • Yelp's review recommendation system uses hundreds of signals and intentionally filters out reviews it cannot verify as organic, so asking customers directly to leave a Yelp review can cause those reviews to be suppressed.
  • Claiming your Yelp page, keeping attributes current, and responding to reviews are actions Yelp says its most successful contractors take beyond just collecting reviews.
  • Yelp scores tend to run lower than Google or other platforms by design, so a gap between your Google rating and your Yelp rating does not necessarily mean something is wrong with your account.
  • Yelp reports sending more than 350,000 home services leads per day, which means contractors who have written off the platform may be missing a meaningful source of inbound demand.
  • Yelp content is cited by Google AI Mode 72 percent of the time for home services queries, so the quality of your Yelp presence has growing implications for how AI tools surface your business.
  • Hatch, now owned by Yelp, is expanding its AI tools for lead management and customer follow-up, so contractors already using Hatch should watch for product changes coming from the combined company.